Is it better to sell crochet on Etsy or at craft fairs?
Neither is universally better — they cost you in different ways. Etsy takes fees on every sale (about 9.5% plus $0.45 for US sellers, more with Offsite Ads) and you pay for shipping supplies. Craft fairs have upfront booth fees, travel and a full day of your time, spread across however many items you sell.
A craft fair with strong sales can be cheaper per item than Etsy. A quiet one can cost far more.
What does it cost to sell one item on Etsy?
Take a crochet hat priced at $45 with free shipping. Etsy's US fees:
| Fee | Amount |
|---|---|
| Listing fee | $0.20 |
| Transaction fee (6.5%) | $2.93 |
| Payment processing (3% + $0.25) | $1.60 |
| Total Etsy fees | $4.73 |
You receive about $40.28, then pay for the mailer and postage. If the sale came through an Offsite Ad, add 15% (or 12% for shops that have ever made $10,000 in a 365-day period) (Etsy's fee policy). How much Etsy takes per sale explains each fee.
What does it cost to sell one item at a craft fair?
Craft-fair costs are mostly fixed, so the cost per item depends on how much you sell. For a hypothetical fair:
| Cost | Example |
|---|---|
| Booth fee | $60 |
| Table display, signage (spread over many fairs) | Varies |
| Card-reader fees | Your reader's rate on card sales |
| Travel | Fuel, parking |
| Your day at the booth | Often 6–10 hours |
If you sell 20 items, a $60 booth fee is $3 per item. If you sell 5, it's $12 per item — much more than Etsy's fees. And the hours spent staffing the booth are real work that isn't in your crochet time.
How should you price across both channels?
A few approaches work well:
- Price for your most expensive channel. If Etsy fees and shipping supplies are your biggest per-item cost, set prices that cover them, and enjoy the extra margin at good fairs.
- Keep prices consistent. Buyers who find you at a fair may look up your Etsy shop later. Big price differences can feel unfair.
- Treat fair costs as overhead. Add booth fees and supplies into your overhead percentage when you calculate prices, rather than hoping sales cover them.
- Know your fair break-even. Divide the booth fee and travel by your average profit per item to see how many sales a fair needs before it pays off.
What about your time at the fair?
A full day at a booth is work, even if it doesn't feel like crochet. Many makers count it as marketing — meeting customers, getting feedback, gathering email sign-ups — rather than trying to charge it to individual items. Just be honest with yourself about whether a fair is paying for your day.
Which items suit each channel?
- Craft fairs often suit touchable, giftable, impulse-priced items — small amigurumi, accessories, seasonal pieces.
- Etsy often suits items people search for specifically — named patterns, custom commissions, gifts ordered ahead of an occasion.
Large, time-heavy pieces like blankets can struggle in both places unless they're priced for their hours, as covered in how much to charge for a crochet blanket.
FAQ
Crochet Pricing Calculator
Price your crochet so the hours you put in actually get paid — and see what the 3× materials rule really earns you.
Outgrowing Etsy?
Once a shop sells enough, its own store can cost less than Etsy's fees: around 134 orders a month for a typical $30 order. See where your break-even point is.
Written by
Founder, ToolsForge
Founder of ToolsForge and a WordPress & WooCommerce developer. Builds the free calculators on this site and writes the guides behind them — every guide pairs real, sourced numbers with a tool so you can run your own.




